Pubdate: Wed, 15 Nov 2000
Source: Toronto Star (CN ON)
Copyright: 2000 The Toronto Star
Contact:  One Yonge St., Toronto ON, M5E 1E6
Fax: (416) 869-4322
Website: http://www.thestar.com/
Forum: http://www.thestar.com/editorial/disc_board/
Author: Theresa Boyle, Queen's Park Bureau

WELFARE DRUG TEST PLAN SETS OFF STORM

`No Cash If You Fail' Proposal Has Critics Lashing Out At Tories

The Ontario government has introduced a controversial plan to force 
welfare recipients to undergo mandatory drug tests because it doesn't 
want them ``shooting their welfare cheques up their arms,'' Social 
Services Minister John Baird says.

Holding a fistful of hypodermic needles to dramatically demonstrate 
his point, Baird said yesterday any welfare recipient who tests 
positive for illegal drugs and refuses treatment will be ineligible 
for social assistance.

``Anyone who refuses to take treatment will lose their benefits,'' he 
warned, adding that the government is embarking on consultations on 
the plan.

The plan, which would be the first in Canada, immediately angered 
activists who say such a move would violate human rights, and harm 
children and single mothers.

Ontario Human Rights Commissioner Keith Norton has said he's 
concerned the proposal would violate civil liberties.

Baird insisted the plan was altruistic and not punitive, though he 
conceded it may involve the police.

``Our government is not prepared to simply turn its back and write 
anyone off,'' Baird said. ``It's difficult to get a job if you're 
addicted to drugs.''

The proposal is subject to a six-week consultation process during 
which the province will meet with municipalities and legal experts to 
hammer out details.

Baird said he isn't sure how many welfare recipients are fighting 
addictions. But he added only 250 people are on the Ontario 
Disability Support Program because of an addiction.

Opposition critics immediately attacked the program.

This ``has certainly more to do with welfare bashing than it does 
with any honest attempt to deal with the complex issue of 
addictions,'' charged Liberal MPP Michael Gravelle (Thunder 
Bay-Superior North).

Andrea Calver, of the Ontario Coalition for Social Justice, said 
mandatory drug testing stigmatizes welfare recipients.

She said it would have a serious impact on single mothers and 
children, who were a large part of the 450,000 Ontarians currently on 
welfare.

``Half of the people on welfare are children, and they're going to be 
impacted by this legislation because the government wants to kick 
more people off welfare,'' said Calver.

``It's wrong.''

If the province really wanted to help them it should do more to 
provide child care, she said.

Dennis Long, of the Ontario Federation of Community Mental Health and 
Addiction programs, said agencies are already struggling with a 
shortage of resources.

Some addiction programs have waiting lists six months long, he said, 
expressing concern about any extra demands on the system.

Ontario Premier Mike Harris defended the program yesterday, insisting 
the goal was to provide help.

``We ought not, just because somebody's hooked on drugs or alcohol . 
. . to give up on them,'' he said outside a government caucus meeting.

``We ought to be doing everything that we can to be providing 
rehabilitation and assistance.''

Ontario cites several American jurisdictions, including Oregon, 
Maryland, Nevada and North Carolina which have already integrated 
substance abuse treatment into their welfare reforms.

And in July, the Ontario Court of Appeal ruled that ``substance 
abusers are handicapped and entitled to the protection of the (Human 
Rights) Code.''
- ---
MAP posted-by: Josh Sutcliffe