Pubdate: Sat, 13 Jan 2001
Source: San Jose Mercury News (CA)
Copyright: 2001 San Jose Mercury News
Contact:  750 Ridder Park Drive, San Jose, CA 95190
Fax: (408) 271-3792
Website: http://www.sjmercury.com/
Forum: http://forums.bayarea.com/webx/cgi-bin/WebX
Authors: Sandra Gonzales And Roxanne Stites, Mercury News
Note: Mercury News reporter Gil Duran contributed to this story.

IN TRAGIC ACCIDENT, UNDERCOVER AGENT KILLED BY FELLOW COPS

Veteran Of Oakland Force Had Pursued Theft Suspect

Two rookie Oakland police officers opened fire late Thursday night on an 
undercover drug agent who had just collared a fleeing auto theft suspect, 
not realizing until after the mortally wounded officer slumped to the 
ground that he was one of their own.

The death of 29-year-old William A. Wilkins -- a seven-year veteran of the 
Oakland Police Department and member of the Alameda County Narcotics Task 
Force, slammed a department recently tainted with scandal, and triggered a 
large-scale investigation into how a tragedy of this magnitude could have 
happened.

It took the two officers who shot at Wilkins just a few moments to realize 
the horrible mistake they had made, according to one witness who lives next 
to the scene of the shooting.

The officers, Kim Davis said, cautiously walked up, and at five feet away, 
saw his face.

"They started calling out his name. 'Willie. Willie. It's Willie,' " Davis 
said.

Wilkins then collapsed backward. The victim's colleagues continued to plead 
with him to keep his eyes open. "Just hold on," Davis said they told 
Wilkins. "Just keep breathing."

The officers tore Wilkins' shirt off and saw his navy blue police uniform.

It was a scene that Davis and others described as "hysterical," with as 
many as seven officers gathered around Wilkins' slumped body in the minutes 
after the shooting.

Officers cried, hugged and shook their heads in disbelief. Others gathered 
around Wilkins, trying to hold him as they waited for paramedics. CPR was 
attempted, but his eyes were shut.

Ambulance crews took Wilkins to Highland Hospital, where he died at 2:20 
a.m. He was married and had a 10-month-old son, William.

Police officials said the two officers -- both on the force no more than a 
year -- may have fired as many as 11 rounds at Wilkins. Some of them struck 
the officer in the upper torso. Davis said she clearly saw one bullet hole 
in his side.

Other shots struck Davis' pink and cream home. One bullet landed in a 
12-inch round brass flower pot. Another ended up on the couch.

Police administrators have not disclosed whether Wilkins tried to identify 
himself but went unheard.

Police Lt. Paul Berlin said officers generally do not use lethal force 
unless there is a perceived threat of a life being taken, whether it's 
their own or someone else's. He said he did not know whether the officers 
shouted any commands before firing.

"In the perfect situation, he would identify himself and show his badge, 
but it depends on the situation," Berlin said.

Other undercover officers said that in a rapidly changing situation, it's 
hard to predict how an officer would react, but that they are told to 
identify themselves immediately. Undercover officers usually wear their 
badge inside their clothing.

"When you're in one of those life-and-death situations, that's not the 
first thing on your mind," said Sgt. Fred Mestas, who worked undercover in 
the narcotics unit.

Theft suspect arrested

Officers arrested one of the two auto thief suspects, who they later 
confirmed was 18-year-old Demetrius Phillips. According to the Oakland city 
jail booking log, Phillips lives in the 1600 block of 87th Avenue in 
Oakland, not far from the shooting scene.

The Alameda County District Attorney's Office is reviewing the shooting to 
determine whether Phillips could be charged with homicide in connection 
with Wilkins' death.

Thursday's incident was another black eye for the Oakland department, which 
became embroiled in a public relations nightmare after the revelation in 
November that four officers were under investigation for allegedly 
falsifying police reports, planting evidence, providing informants with 
drugs and using excessive force.

Both of the officers involved in the shooting Thursday night are in their 
early twenties and had been at the department for less than a year. They 
were placed on paid administrative leave.

"We're giving them time to collect themselves and seek the support they 
need right now," said Berlin, leader of the investigation. Berlin, who said 
it was the first shooting involving Oakland officers killing a fellow 
officer that he could recall in his 20-year career, said it did not appear 
that Wilkins had fired any shots, nor was it clear how Wilkins knew the car 
was stolen.

Officers are reviewing radio dispatch transcripts. Ideally, Berlin said, an 
undercover officer would have called dispatch and identified himself as 
entering a pursuit.

At a morning news conference, Oakland Police Chief Richard Word described 
the incident as a tragedy and expressed sympathy for Wilkins' family. And, 
at the Oakland Police Association headquarters, officers grieved.

Facing a tragedy

"This is the kind of thing that we hope never happens, but in the course of 
human events, these things do happen," said Mayor Jerry Brown during a news 
conference at police headquarters.

Just before the late-night shooting, Wilkins sat alone in an unmarked car, 
staking out an East Oakland neighborhood, when he saw the driver of a 
stolen car speed past. Wilkins took off after the car, police said Friday, 
pursuing the car for just a few blocks.

An armed Wilkins gave chase as the suspects ran through yards and 
apparently collared one of them in a driveway on B Street near 91st Avenue 
when the two uniformed officers arrived.

At that point, shots were fired.

"The shots were so intense, I knew the shots were coming through my house," 
said Davis, who woke up to gunfire about 11:15 p.m. Fearing for herself and 
her two children, the 41-year-old Oakland resident jumped out of bed and 
slowly crept across the living room to peek out the front-door window.

What she saw and heard hit her like a brick, she said: An injured, bloodied 
man slumped to his knees on her driveway, and officers were pointing guns 
at him.

Police have released few details about the events leading up to the 
shooting, and officials have said they are not releasing the names of the 
officers involved in the shooting.

Many neighbors of the East Oakland neighborhood are questioning why they 
had to pull the trigger.

Wilkins was described as a popular officer who also worked on a tactical 
response team. The stream of officers who solemnly stood before a memorial 
set up in the station lobby gave evidence of his popularity.

Wilkins began working at the department in 1991 as a cadet and became an 
officer in 1993. He had been in the narcotics unit for two years.

Mercury News reporter Gil Duran contributed to this story.
- ---
MAP posted-by: Jo-D