Pubdate: Tue, 24 Jul 2001
Source: Los Angeles Times (CA)
Copyright: 2001 Los Angeles Times
Contact:  http://www.latimes.com/
Details: http://www.mapinc.org/media/248
Author: Matt Lait and Scott Glover, Times Staff Writers
Note: Times staff writer Miles Corwin contributed to this story.
Bookmark: http://www.mapinc.org/rampart.htm (L.A. Rampart Scandal)

JUDGE ORDERS PEREZ FREED FROM PRISON

Court: Whistle-Blower In The LAPD Rampart Scandal Kept 'His End Of 
The Bargain,' Jurist Says.

Rafael A. Perez, the former Los Angeles police officer whose 
allegations of police misconduct plunged the LAPD into a wrenching 
period of investigation and reform, was ordered released from prison 
Monday by a judge who ruled that he lived "up to his end of the 
bargain" by cooperating with authorities.

Citing concerns about Perez's safety, state prison officials declined 
to say precisely when or where the former Rampart Division officer 
would be set free. They would only confirm that they will comply with 
Superior Court Judge Robert J. Perry's order to release Perez within 
24 hours of Monday morning's ruling.

The order releasing Perez, 33, ends a chapter in the Rampart police 
corruption probe. Even as authorities continue to prosecute some 
officers and hunt for others who may have been involved in crimes, 
the central figure in the scandal will walk out of prison a free man 
less than three years after his initial arrest for stealing three 
kilograms of cocaine from LAPD evidence facilities. While Perez's 
past has been well documented, the future for the man who identified 
dozens of allegedly crooked officers and victimized hundreds of gang 
members remains complicated and uncertain.

District attorney officials said Monday they plan to appeal Perez's 
release on grounds that the judge exceeded his authority. If they 
succeed, Perez may be forced back to prison to serve additional time 
on his five-year sentence.

Federal authorities, meanwhile, are still considering whether they 
will seek to indict Perez for corruption-related offenses, which they 
continue to investigate.

He could play a role in other potential prosecutions arising from the 
D.A.'s and LAPD's ongoing probes. But until the federal investigation 
is resolved, it's unlikely he will be called as a witness.

As for Perez's immediate plans, he wants to reunite with his wife and 
family and keep a low profile, his attorney said. Monday evening, 
several people arrived at the Perez home, one woman carrying several 
bags of food, as Perez's wife apparently waited inside.

Since he was incarcerated, Perez has become a deeply religious man 
who "wants to be a productive member of society," attorney Winston 
Kevin McKesson said.

But any plans that Perez may have "to do good deeds in the community" 
may be difficult to achieve, McKesson said.

"He certainly has concerns about his safety," McKesson said. "He 
doesn't know who would want to take a potshot at him."

Perez Could Leave The State

Because of those concerns, Judge Perry said Perez will be permitted 
to seek parole arrangements out of state if he desires.

The ex-officer has been praised and vilified for his work as the key 
informant in the Rampart corruption probe. Civil rights advocates 
have said he helped to crack the police code of silence and spurred 
much-needed reforms at the LAPD.

Some in law enforcement, however, have questioned Perez's veracity 
and blamed him for putting the entire Police Department under a cloud 
of public distrust.

"It's hard to imagine that Rafael Perez could ever fully serve his 
debt to society," the LAPD police union said in a prepared statement 
Monday. "Regardless of his release date . . . it is too soon. He has 
tarnished the image of the hard-working men and women that make up 
the rank and file of the LAPD and disappointed the people of Los 
Angeles."

Perez's release was set in motion early Monday when Perry sought to 
resolve a controversy over whether he should receive state 
"work-time" credits for the time he spent in jail cooperating with 
authorities after he was sentenced in February 2000.

Those credits would allow Perez a day off his sentence for every day 
he served in a state prison. Under such a calculation, Perez's 
attorney has argued, his client should have been released last month.

Prosecutors and prison officials, however, said that because Perez 
served his time in a county jail and was not sent to a state facility 
until just two weeks ago, he is not entitled to those credits.

District attorney officials argued that Perez was never promised 
work-time credit. And, they noted, his plea deal makes no mention of 
it.

But the judge rejected that argument. At the time of sentencing, he 
said, all parties mistakenly believed that Perez would earn those 
credits in county jail. He said Perez should not have to suffer for 
their mistakes.

"We have a defendant," Perry said, "who cooperated and in a very real 
sense furthered the cause of justice in this community and is placed 
in a position where he is being harmed because of his cooperation."

The judge added: "He did live up to his end of the bargain."

As Perry handed down his ruling, the once-swaggering anti-gang cop 
wept. His attorney placed his arm around Perez's shoulder. Perez's 
wife and other relatives and friends who attended the hearing cried.

Prosecutors petitioned the state Court of Appeal to halt Perez's 
release, but the appellate court denied the petition without comment.

Perez traded his LAPD uniform for county jail blues in 1998 when he 
was arrested and charged with stealing six pounds of cocaine from 
LAPD evidence facilities. He pleaded not guilty and took his chances 
before a jury.

At first, the gamble appeared to pay off. The handsome, charismatic 
ex-cop was an excellent witness on his own behalf, and the jury hung 
8 to 4 in favor of a conviction.

But authorities weren't finished. Under the direction of Deputy Dist. 
Atty. Richard Rosenthal, LAPD investigators gathered more evidence 
linking Perez to the missing cocaine.

He also was indicted on charges of stealing two additional pounds 
that were discovered missing.

Meanwhile, Perez would later say, he was lying awake in his jail 
cell, reflecting on some of his then-unknown misdeeds as a police 
officer. His mistreatment of one man in particular, Javier Francisco 
Ovando, weighed heavily on his mind.

Whatever his motivation, as his second trial was to begin, Perez's 
lawyer approached Rosenthal about a plea bargain. Faced with a 
possible 12-year sentence for cocaine theft, Perez would serve five 
years in exchange for identifying other corrupt officers. What 
followed was a series of admissions and allegations that would rock 
not only the LAPD, but the entire Los Angeles County criminal justice 
system.

He first told authorities about Ovando, who he claims had been coming 
to him in dreams. Perez said he and then-partner Nino Durden shot 
Ovando, who was unarmed, several times. He said they then planted a 
gun on him and testified in court that he had attacked them, helping 
to send him to prison for 23 years.

Ovando was out of prison within days of Perez's admission, and has 
since been paid $15 million by the city to settle a civil rights 
lawsuit.

In the coming weeks and months, Perez would implicate about 70 
officers as having been involved in crimes or misconduct or knowing 
about them and doing nothing.

He said the corruption was centered in the anti-gang CRASH unit he 
was assigned to in the Rampart Division. The unit, he said, mimicked 
the gangs it policed, with many of its members wearing skull tattoos 
with the dead man's hand of aces and eights.

Perez's statements to investigators led to the overturning of more 
than 100 criminal convictions, because prosecutors lost faith in the 
credibility of their police witnesses. Most of those cases involved 
Perez and Durden as arresting officers. In addition to his role in 
the Ovando case, Perez said Durden routinely stole drugs and money 
from suspects.

Durden denied any wrongdoing for more than a year.

But in March, in a surprise development, he pleaded guilty to a host 
of state and federal charges, including planting a gun on Ovando and 
providing false testimony against him in court. Durden is continuing 
to cooperate with federal authorities as he awaits imposition of his 
anticipated eight-year sentence.

Seven other officers have been charged with crimes as a result of 
Perez's allegations.

Four were convicted by a jury of corruption-related offenses, but 
their convictions were overturned. That outcome has been appealed by 
the district attorney's office.
- ---
MAP posted-by: Kirk