Pubdate: Thu, 01 Feb 2001
Source: Press Democrat, The (CA)
Copyright: 2001 The Press Democrat
Contact:  Letters Editor, P. O. Box 569, Santa Rosa CA 95402
Fax: (707) 521-5305
Feedback: http://www.pressdemocrat.com/opinion/letform.html
Website: http://www.pressdemo.com/
Forum: http://www.pressdemo.com/opinion/talk/
Author: Clark Mason, The Press Democrat

COURT GIVES MARIJUANA BACK

SSU Student's Pot Was Confiscated Despite Doctor's Written Recommendation

In a rare turn of events, a medical marijuana patient got his pot back 
Wednesday after a Sonoma County judge ordered authorities to return it.

Earlier in the week, prosecutors dropped a marijuana possession charge 
against Ross Benbrook, a Sonoma State University student, who was arrested 
in October by Rohnert Park police for having just under an ounce of marijuana.

Superior Court Judge Elliot Lee Daum said the marijuana should be returned, 
and on Wednesday it was handed to Benbrook in court.

"It's nice to get my medicine back. I feel this should never have happened 
in the first place," Benbrook said afterward.

Medical marijuana advocates said Benbrook is one of a handful of people in 
the state to have a judge order that their confiscated marijuana be returned.

It happened once before in Sonoma County -- a year ago when Scott Teeter, 
an Agua Caliente man with approval from his doctor, had more than a pound 
returned to him by order of Judge Gayle Guynup.

Prosecutors objected to the return of Teeter's marijuana. But on Wednesday, 
District Attorney Mike Mullins noted that his office did not oppose the 
motion by Benbrook's defense attorney to return his.

Mullins said the Benbrook case is an example of the need for some sort of 
statewide, standardized identification cards for medical marijuana patients.

"This is another example of the message I'm attempting to get across. This 
statute cries out for clarity," Mullins said of the 1996 ballot initiative 
that approved the use of marijuana for medicinal purposes.

Mullins said Benbrook's signature on his driver's license didn't seem to 
match the one on his doctor's recommendation. He said police had no 
immediate way to verify the approval from his Berkeley doctor.

Benbrook, a 23-year-old psychology major, said he was stopped for allegedly 
making an illegal left turn to avoid a sobriety checkpoint.

During the traffic stop, officers detected the potent scent of fresh 
marijuana buds.

Benbrook said he showed police the doctor's written recommendation that he 
has to use marijuana to alleviate pain for his "traumatic arthritis and 
scoliosis."

"In the police report, they said the document appeared to be false," 
Benbrook said.

Benbrook's stash was confiscated and he was released after promising to 
appear in court.

Earlier this week, after a jury acquitted Alan MacFarlane on charges of 
marijuana cultivation, he vowed to seek the return of his plants, although 
most were destroyed by authorities.
- ---
MAP posted-by: Jo-D