Pubdate: Thu, 29 Nov 2001
Source: Palm Beach Post (FL)
Copyright: 2001 The Palm Beach Post
Contact:  http://www.gopbi.com/
Details: http://www.mapinc.org/media/333
Author: Kathryn Quigley

DRUG EVIDENCE TOSSED BECAUSE ROADBLOCK RULES FOUND LACKING

WEST PALM BEACH -- An appeals court on Wednesday threw out drug evidence 
from an arrest made during a roadblock, saying the West Palm Beach Police 
Department's guidelines for roadblocks do not contain specific information 
about drug searches.

Earnest D. Jones, 38, of Riviera Beach was stopped at 32nd Street and 
Broadway on Jan. 11, 2000, during a vehicle safety inspection roadblock in 
which every car was stopped. He was cited for not having insurance or 
registration cards.

According to court records, the officers asked to search his vehicle and he 
refused. An officer said he saw marijuana seeds on the seat of the car. 
Police then searched the car and found a small amount of cocaine and 
marijuana. They found more drugs on Jones as they were arresting him. Jones 
pleaded no contest to drug charges and was sentenced to 18 months in prison.

Jones' lawyer, Robert Norvell, argued that the vehicle search itself was 
flawed and therefore all evidence collected must be suppressed.

A three-judge panel from the 4th District Court of Appeal agreed, saying 
Circuit Judge Howard Berman should have excluded the drug evidence. The 
panel's ruling states that the police department's written guidelines for 
the roadblock were inadequate because they did not mention the presence or 
duties of narcotics officers.

Courts generally have allowed police to conduct roadblocks in the interest 
of public safety, such as to check for seat belt use and drunken drivers. 
But the police must use written guidelines so drivers are not stopped or 
searched arbitrarily, courts have ruled.

Capt. Delsa Bush, a supervisor with the police department's road patrol, 
said the department will discuss the ruling. But she said she doesn't 
anticipate any changes to the written guidelines officers use.

"Certainly we want to follow the rules," she said.

But the department also has the right to arrest drivers on drug charges if 
the drugs are in plain view, she said.

The attorney general's office said it is considering whether to ask for 
another hearing on the matter.

Norvell said prosecutors should drop the charges against Jones because the 
drug evidence was the crux of the case.
- ---
MAP posted-by: Keith Brilhart