Pubdate: Mon, 27 May 2002
Source: Courier Herald, The (GA)
Copyright: 2002 Courier Herald
Contact:  http://www.courier-herald.com/
Details: http://www.mapinc.org/media/2132
Author: Stephanie Miller

LAWMAN FILES LAWSUIT AGAINST DISTRICT ATTORNEY LAWSUIT AGAINST 
DISTRICT ATTORNEY

Dublin-Laurens County Drug Unit Officer's Suit Alleges Slander, Libel

An officer of the Dublin-Laurens County Drug Unit has filed suit 
against District Attorney Ralph Walke alleging slander, libel and 
breach of duties/responsibilities as district attorney. Christopher 
Brewer filed suit against Walke, both individually and in his 
official capacity as district attorney, through Savannah attorney 
Derek J. White. The suit alleges that "as a result of Walke's 
inaccurate perception of (Brewer's) testimonies in legal proceeding, 
(Walke) has told members of the community that he would not prosecute 
any criminal cases that involved any investigations or arrests 
performed by (Brewer)" and that "on March 13, 2002 (Walke) told 
(Brewer's) employer and supervisors that (Brewer) had committed 
perjury on at least six different occasions and subsequent to the 
alleged statements (Walke) had (Brewer's) supervisor retrieve 
warrants prepared by (Brewer) from (Walke's) office because (Walke) 
refused to prosecute the warrants solely because they were prepared 
by (Brewer)." The reasons behind Walke's alleged statements and 
actions are not known by Brewer or his attorney. "That's what we're 
trying to find out," said White. "We do think it will come out in 
discovery." White said Laurens County Sheriff Kenny Webb has not made 
any move to remove Brewer from his job, but he feels sure if the 
district attorney won't prosecute Brewer's cases it will eventually 
affect his job. "The sheriff is responsible to the people of Laurens 
County," said White. "Why should the sheriff keep him on the payroll? 
Down the line of course I think Mr. Brewer would be released." White 
explained that if any case Brewer brings to the district attorney 
won't be prosecuted, then criminals can commit those crimes without 
worrying about punishment. "Not only has Mr. Brewer's professional 
character been attacked but the people of Laurens County will have to 
pay," said White. White said the district attorney has the right to 
choose which cases he prosecutes on behalf of the people. The suit 
also indicates that Walke allegedly made statements that Brewer is 
"involved in illegal activities with attorneys in the Dublin Judicial 
Circuit" and that Brewer, as well as other deputy sheriffs on the 
drug unit, were "receiving monies, illegally, to insure that certain 
cases would not be prosecuted." Brewer has been a deputy with the 
Laurens County Sheriff's Department for more than 10 years. He has 
been a member of the Interstate Criminal Enforcement Team and Drug 
Unit for at least four years, according to a Laurens County Sheriff's 
Department spokesman. Efforts to reach Walke and Brewer before 
presstime failed. The suit shows that on April 18, 2002 Brewer 
requested Walke correct and retract the libelous and slanderous 
statements. Walke received the request on April 19, 2002 and on April 
23 declined to retract his "libelous and slanderous statements" 
concerning Brewer. The lawsuit was filed May 17, 2002 - 28 days after 
Walke received notice of Brewer's request. Attached to the law suit 
is also a letter from Attorney General Thurbert E. Baker's office 
addressed to White dated April 23, 2002, stating that Walke has "no 
intention of retracting" any statements he allegedly made since "none 
of the statements were defamatory or libelous in any fashion." The 
letter also states that Senior Assistant Attorney General John C. 
Jones would be representing Walke and all correspondence should be 
directed to him. Efforts to reach Jones before presstime also failed. 
The suit alleges Walke committed libel by "printing false information 
about (Brewer's) professional character and being; writing false 
information about (Brewer's) professional character and being; and by 
providing false information about (Brewer's) professional character 
and being to others for public dissemination." The suit also implies 
that as a direct result Brewer was "personally and professionally 
humiliated, embarrassed and upset. His peace of mind, happiness, and 
feelings were irreparably wounded as a direct and proximate result of 
defendant placing him in a false light before the public; his peers; 
and most importantly, his employer." The suit goes on to allege Walke 
committed slander when he "imputed to (Brewer) his involvement in 
illegal activities, with attorneys and other members of the Laurens 
County Sheriff's drug unit, crimes punishable by law; charging 
(Brewer) with committing perjury, a crime punishable by law; and 
making charges against (Brewer) in reference to his trade and 
profession, calculated to injure him therein; and providing the above 
false information to others for public dissemination." The suit also 
alleges Walke breached his duties and responsibilities as district 
attorney "by failing to prosecute any and all criminal activities 
properly brought to (his) attention by (Brewer) as a peace officer; 
by imputing to plaintiff, as a peace officer, acts of perjury; by 
imputing to plaintiff, as a peace officer, the committing of crimes 
punishable by law; and by disseminating false information about 
plaintiff, as a peace officer." White said Walke has 30 days to 
answer the suit then a "discovery" will take place. A discovery is 
the process of gathering all information before trial, usually within 
a period of six months. White said Brewer filed the suit to protect 
his reputation, his future and his family. He said Brewer hasn't 
considered any monetary gains he may receive from the suit. "It's not 
the money," said White. "We haven't even talked about money. It's his 
job he's trying to save. He's trying to keep a roof over his family's 
head by keeping a job."
- ---
MAP posted-by: Josh