Pubdate: Tue, 21 Jan 2003
Source: Age, The (Australia)
Copyright: 2003 The Age Company Ltd
Contact:  http://www.theage.com.au/
Details: http://www.mapinc.org/media/5
Author: Ruth Pollard

SMOKES, ALCOHOL 'MOST DAMAGING DRUGS'

Tobacco and alcohol account for 83 per cent of the cost of drug abuse in 
Australia, dwarfing the financial impact of illegal drugs.

A Commonwealth Government report estimates that in 1998-99 tobacco 
accounted for $21 billion, or 60 per cent, of the adverse costs of drugs to 
individuals, business and government, and alcohol made up $7.5 billion, or 
22 per cent.

But the illicit drug toll is fast catching up with alcohol, accounting for 
$6 billion, or 17 per cent of total costs, according to the report, 
Counting the Cost, produced for the Federal Government's National Drug 
Strategy.

One of the report's authors, adjunct professor in economics at Macquarie 
University, David Collins, said the report had measured, for the first 
time, the cost of passive smoking to the community.

"A lot of the impact of . . . involuntary smoking is on the unborn child 
and on children under 14 years. It hits the young very hard because they 
have no control over their lives," he said.

Measuring hospital bed days, other health care costs and deaths in 1998-99, 
the report found involuntary smoking cost the community $47 million.

"Tobacco is still the greatest killer by far and imposes the greatest 
costs," Professor Collins said. The cost of fires resulting from smoking 
was put at $81 million.

"The message from this report is that the costs (of drug use) are so high 
the potential benefit of a small reduction is substantial," Professor 
Collins said.

"Anti-tobacco programs yield very high rates of return, and the same is 
true for illicit drugs."

The problem of alcohol use was more complex because it had beneficial as 
well as damaging effects on drinkers.

"If you reduce alcohol consumption you may reduce the benefits," Professor 
Collins said. "That said, people should not be encouraged to binge drink. 
It is moderate, low-level consumption that provides the benefit."

The report estimates that in 1998-99 alcohol caused 4286 deaths, but 
prevented 7029.

The costs of drug use include both the tangible - crime, policing, cancer, 
hospital bed days, car accidents, death, fires, loss of productivity, less 
tax revenue - and the intangible, such as pain and suffering due to illness 
and death.

Based on surveys and interviews with people in police custody and prisons 
done by the Australian Institute of Criminology, the report estimates that 
the cost of drug crime totals $4.6 billion.

Illicit drugs make up $2.9 billion and alcohol contributes $1.7 billion.
- ---
MAP posted-by: Jo-D