Pubdate: Fri, 27 Oct 2006
Source: Victoria Times-Colonist (CN BC)
Copyright: 2006 Times Colonist
Contact:  http://www.canada.com/victoriatimescolonist/
Details: http://www.mapinc.org/media/481
Author: Norma Greenaway, CanWest News Service

MEDICAL POT CRUSADER WINS NEW TRIAL

OTTAWA -- A medical marijuana crusader from Alberta will get a new 
trial on drug charges after the Supreme Court of Canada ruled 
unanimously yesterday the judge in his original trial had reduced the 
jury's role to a "ceremonial" one.

In a 7-0 judgment, the top court said Grant Krieger of Calgary was 
deprived of his "constitutional right" to a trial by jury when the 
judge in the case directed the jury to find the accused guilty of 
possession of marijuana for the purposes of trafficking. It quashed 
Krieger's conviction and ordered a new trial by jury.

"The trial judge's direction was not a 'slip of the tongue,"' Justice 
Morris Fish wrote on behalf of the court. "His purpose and words were 
clear. In effect, the trial judge reduced the jury's role to a ceremonial one."

Krieger, 51, uses marijuana to help cope with his multiple sclerosis. 
Krieger said he was overjoyed by the ruling, and the prospect of a 
new trial. He said he is confident a "jury of his peers" will find 
him not guilty of the charges.

"I'm walking in the same steps as Henry Morgentaler was walking over 
abortion and female issues," he said in an interview from Calgary. 
"I'm doing the same thing for the sick, injured and dying on the 
cannabis issue."

At the original trial, Krieger confessed to providing marijuana to 
others in medical need, but he defended his actions on grounds he had 
no choice other than to break the law to ensure a reliable supply of 
pot for patients who have a federal exemption for marijuana use.

Before leaving the court room, the judge told jurors to convict, and 
said they were "bound to abide by that direction." He later rejected 
two jurors' requests to be excused on religious grounds and grounds 
of conscience. The jury subsequently returned with a guilty verdict.

The verdict was upheld in the Alberta Court of Appeal. Although it 
said trial Judge Paul Chrumka made a mistake in ordering the jury to 
convict, it said a new trial would result in the same verdict. Chief 
Justice Catherine Fraser dissented, which meant the case was 
automatically put to the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court ruling confirmed what Fish cited as the 
well-established notion that juries have the power to refuse to apply 
the law when their consciences permit no other course.

John Hooker, Krieger's lawyer, had argued the top court had formally 
recognized the option of so-called jury nullification in a 1988 
ruling that upheld the jury acquittal of abortion doctor Morgentaler. 
Hooker said the top court would have delivered a devastating blow to 
the role of juries in the Canadian judicial system if it had upheld 
the guilty verdict. Hooker said he expects a new trial can begin 
within the next four or five months.

Krieger's legal journey began seven years ago when police seized 29 
marijuana plants from his Calgary home. Since then, he's become an 
outspoken activist, and was recently convicted in Alberta provincial 
court of two new drug trafficking charges. His sentencing is slated 
for February.
- ---
MAP posted-by: Elaine