Pubdate: Wed, 23 May 2007
Source: San Francisco Bay Guardian, The (CA)
Copyright: 2007 San Francisco Bay Guardian
Contact:  http://www.sfbg.com/
Details: http://www.mapinc.org/media/387

PRISON INSANITY

The Dumbest, Most Expensive, And Least Effective Solution To Crime Is 
To Build More Prisons

The dumbest, most expensive, and least effective solution to crime is 
to build more prisons. We have about 20 years of empirical data to 
prove that, right in California. Yet the state legislature and the 
governor have agreed to spend $8 billion, mostly in new bond money, 
to expand the bloated state prison system.

California currently locks up 173,000 people. Texas, that great 
liberal bastion of criminal coddling, only has 152,000 inmates. It's 
staggering -- and the billions this state has spent on cell blocks 
have had no measurable impact on the crime rate.

In fact, California has the highest prison return rate in the nation: 
seven in 10 people released from state prisons wind up behind bars 
again. The state's ridiculously tough parole laws allow offenders to 
be locked up again for minor, harmless infractions.

The entire state corrections system is in such bad shape that the 
federal courts have threatened to throw it into receivership if some 
of the more glaring problems aren't addressed. That's why this 
package was rushed through without adequate debate and why so many 
Democrats went along with it.

But the bill that the legislature passed does nothing to address 
those problems.

The centerpiece of the measure is an ambitious, very expensive plan 
to build 53,000 new prison beds over the next five years. The sad 
fact is that the construction boom won't do much of anything to solve 
the overcrowding problem: like freeways, prisons fill up as fast as 
they are built. So in five years, the state will have another 50,000 
inmates, and the prisons will still be overcrowded.

And of course, nowhere in the deal is there any proposal for how the 
state will find the extra money to pay the operating costs of all 
these new prison facilities. Instead, the prison budget will continue 
to crowd out social programs (and the bonds will make it harder to 
pass a high-speed rail bond this fall).

Assembly Speaker Fabian Nunez and State Senate President Don Perata 
made statements highly critical of the plan, and Nunez demanded that 
the governor resolve a lot of the lingering problems before the 
construction begins. But they both voted for the bill. (One of the 
few who didn't was Sen. Carole Migden, to her great credit.)

The Democrats in the legislature need to go back and start 
dismantling this bill before it's too late -- and need to take up 
serious sentencing reform. If they won't, activists ought to look at 
a November ballot measure. We don't want to see a federal takeover 
either -- but anything would be better than this mess.
- ---
MAP posted-by: Beth Wehrman