Pubdate: Sun, 12 Oct 2008
Source: New Zealand Herald (New Zealand)
Copyright: 2008 New Zealand Herald
Contact: http://info.nzherald.co.nz/letters/
Website: http://www.nzherald.co.nz/
Details: http://www.mapinc.org/media/300
Author: Jared Savage

UNDERCOVER COP'S LIES SENT 150 TO JAIL

Police have hired one of the country's top lawyers to investigate a 
former officer's stunning confession that he lied in court - and 
wrongfully sent at least 150 people to prison.

Patrick O'Brien wrote to Chief Justice Dame Sian Elias admitting to 
perjury, saying he was racked with guilt after carrying a "dreadful 
secret" for more than 30 years.

Now nearly 60, O'Brien was an undercover agent in covert drugs 
operations in the 1970s, immersed in a dark, criminal underworld, and 
the star Crown witness in the resulting court trials.

However, O'Brien says he lied on oath every time he took the stand.

In the confession letter, he said he could not guess the number of 
people with convictions or imprisoned "because of my lies", because 
he stopped counting arrests at 150, halfway through his three-year stint.

All but one of the juries - in a case where the Crown failed to prove 
a substance was a narcotic - returned with a guilty verdict.

Leading Wellington lawyer Bruce Squire, QC, has been hired by Police 
National Headquarters to investigate the allegations independently.

Squire, who also investigated allegations into the police undercover 
work in 2004, did not return /Herald on Sunday/ calls.

In his confession, O'Brien told Dame Sian he answered to the "grey 
men" who trained him, on whose orders he lied to obtain the 
convictions at any cost.

"They called it Doomsday work and instructed me to take this dreadful 
secret to the grave," O'Brien wrote.

"In every case I lied to the courts and I lied to the juries to 
obtain convictions against my targets.

"Telling lies was easy - 'policemen don't tell lies' - and my targets 
never stood a chance."

Tampering with evidence was also common, he said. Often the exhibit 
before the court was not the drugs that he bought from the target.

He also deceived his operators, usually high-ranked detectives 
stationed in the communities where O'Brien operated undercover.

"Most of these men were tough (real tough) but without exception they 
were honest and would have brooked no time for the methods I employed 
to obtain convictions," O'Brien wrote.

Eventually, the shame and stress of the work broke O'Brien. He 
resigned from the police and fled New Zealand, "haunted, traumatised 
and scared".

"My life since has been a tragic waste; running, always running, but 
never able to lose the demons that rush around in my head.

"I am nearly 60 years old now, and in what time is left to me, intend 
correcting the wrong I have done."

O'Brien was honoured for his undercover work by former 
Governor-General Sir David Beattie, who presided over a series of 
drug trials held in the High Court at Hamilton in 1974.

Sir David wrote to Police Commissioner Ken Burnside with a glowing 
testimony about the young constable who was such a credible witness, 
despite defence counsel questioning his truthfulness.

Later asked why he wrote to the commissioner, Sir David told a radio 
show host he was "impressed with the standards this man had set 
himself, and the risks he had run, and the results he achieved".

O'Brien confessed to Dame Sian: "In every case and on every charge, I 
lied to Sir David and I lied to his juries."

His confession letter was obtained by the Herald on Sunday through 
the Official Information Act.

Police National Headquarters received the letter on Christmas Eve, 
but an investigation did not begin until February.

Police spokesman Jon Neilson would not comment further until the 
investigation was complete.

O'Brien said he would co-operate fully with the inquiry and plead 
guilty to any charges.

Yesterday he told the /Herald on Sunday/ he was "a homeless 
itinerant" currently hitchhiking in the South Island.

"I am not in hiding, nor am I running."

In his confession he said he intended to "start knocking on doors and 
apologise" to those he had helped to wrongfully convict.

"Should any target wish to seek remedy for my wrong, I will assist in 
whatever way I can."

He was not surprised he had not been interviewed by Squire, despite 
almost 300 days passing since his confession.

He had posted open letters on websites and paid for adverts trying to 
make contact with his former targets.

"Following orders is no excuse, I knew what I was doing was wrong," 
said O'Brien.

"Now I will face the truth."

[sidebar]

THE INQUIRY TERMS OF REFERENCE:

Leading lawyer Bruce Squire QC's terms of reference for the inquiry 
require him to:

Identify and clarify that Patrick O'Brien lied and tampered with evidence.

Assess the implications and veracity of the allegations.

Determine whether the police should investigate further.

He will report his findings to Police Commissioner Howard Broad. Even 
if it can be proven, the people convicted and imprisoned on O'Brien's 
false evidence may not necessarily be eligible for compensation.

Cabinet has a base sum of $100,000 awarded for each year wrongly 
spent in jail, though that amount can be higher.

However, rules introduced 10 years ago mean compensation is awarded 
to those wrongly convicted only if they can prove their innocence 
beyond reasonable doubt.

Arthur Allan Thomas received $1 million in 1980 for the 10 years he 
spent in jail. David Dougherty was awarded almost $900,000 in 2001 
after DNA evidence proved him innocent. 
- ---
MAP posted-by: Richard Lake