Pubdate: Sat, 30 Jan 2010
Source: Los Angeles Times (CA)
Page: A12
Copyright: 2010 Los Angeles Times
Contact: http://mapinc.org/url/bc7El3Yo
Website: http://www.latimes.com/
Details: http://www.mapinc.org/media/248
Author: John Hoeffel
Cited: Americans for Safe Access http://www.americansforsafeaccess.org/
Referenced: The Sherman Law http://www.dhs.ca.gov/fdb/html/General/sheindex.htm
Bookmark: http://www.mapinc.org/topic/dispensaries
Bookmark: http://www.mapinc.org/find?115 (Cannabis - California)
Bookmark: http://www.mapinc.org/find?253 (Cannabis - Medicinal - U.S.)

JUDGE ORDERS DISPENSARY TO STOP SELLING MEDICAL POT

A Los Angeles County Superior Court judge Friday ordered an Eagle 
Rock dispensary to stop selling medical marijuana in a decision city 
prosecutors believe is the first to conclude that state law does not 
allow collectives to sell the drug.

Judge James C. Chalfant's preliminary injunction applies only to Hemp 
Factory V, a small outlet on Colorado Boulevard near the Glendale 
border, but would have a dramatic impact on how medical marijuana is 
distributed if a higher court upholds it. The decision came in the 
pretrial phase of the city's lawsuit against the dispensary.

Hundreds of collectives in Los Angeles and throughout California sell 
marijuana, as Hemp Factory V does, to anyone who shows up with a 
doctor's recommendation and signs a form to become a member. The 
state's courts have ruled on many medical marijuana issues, but have 
not directly addressed whether this widespread practice is legal.

Chalfant concluded that collectives can only grow marijuana and 
receive reimbursement for reasonable costs.

"A retail store that sells marijuana to its members simply does not 
satisfy the requirement of a collective to cultivate marijuana," he 
wrote in his 16-page decision.

Anthony P. Malecki, an attorney for Hemp Factory V and its operator, 
Gevork Berberyan, did not challenge Chalfant's conclusions in the 
courtroom. He said he would consult with Berberyan before deciding 
whether to appeal.

The city's attorney, Asha Greenberg, noted that the decision was only 
a trial court ruling, but said that it should be a warning to collectives.

"They should pay attention to it," she said. "A lot of cases have not 
been as clear-cut. This judge's analysis was right on. I think it's 
valuable for that reason."

In his decision, Chalfant endorsed the interpretation of state law 
and recent court decisions advocated by Los Angeles City Atty. Carmen 
Trutanich, who has become one of the most outspoken opponents of 
medical marijuana sales in the state.

Trutanich sued Hemp Factory V in October in his first attempt to use 
the courts to close a dispensary in Los Angeles, which has seen 
hundreds open while city officials failed to enforce a moratorium.

The state law adopted in 2003 to expand on California's 1996 medical 
marijuana initiative allows patients and their caregivers to form 
collectives to cultivate marijuana. It does not explicitly allow 
marijuana to be sold, although the practice is commonplace.

Prosecutors and law enforcement officials have increasingly argued 
that the law allows patients to work cooperatively to cultivate 
marijuana, but not to sell it over the counter.

Dispensary operators, including Berberyan, say they do not sell 
marijuana, but ask for voluntary donations to cover the costs of 
growing marijuana. Many, including Berberyan, also say they give the 
drug free to patients who cannot afford the price, which at Hemp 
Factory is typically around $60 for an eighth of an ounce.

Berberyan, a 33-year-old former truck driver, said in a deposition 
earlier this month that he and six other patients grow marijuana for 
about 500 to 600 members. He said he started to raise pot at the 
dispensary's location in December. In a declaration filed after his 
deposition, he said Hemp Factory V had just 171 members. His attorney 
declined to comment on the discrepancy.

Chalfant said those numbers demonstrate that the dispensary's 
principal function is retail sales, not cultivation. "Hemp Factory's 
evidence does not show that members are collectively raising 
marijuana as a crop," he wrote.

The debate over whether marijuana can be sold, rooted in the law's 
murky language, was one of the main reasons Los Angeles labored many 
months to draft an ordinance. City Council members struggled with 
whether to outlaw sales, as Trutanich and Los Angeles County Dist. 
Atty. Steve Cooley insisted they should. In the end, the council 
skirted the issue, adopting language allowing cash contributions, but 
also requiring dispensaries to comply with state law.

"We did win this issue with City Council, it's unfortunate that this 
judge is going in a different direction," said Joe Elford, the chief 
counsel for Americans for Safe Access, a medical marijuana advocacy 
group. He said Chalfant and the prosecutors have misinterpreted key 
court decisions.

Chalfant's injunction underscores just how much remains unclear about 
the state's medical marijuana laws, even as voters in California are 
likely to decide in November whether to legalize marijuana sales for 
personal use.

The decision could embolden Trutanich and other prosecutors who have 
threatened to pursue dispensaries for selling marijuana. Officials 
with the city attorney's office declined to discuss whether they plan 
to bring additional cases, but the district attorney's office has 
continued to prosecute dispensary operators.

In addition to maintaining that sales are illegal, Trutanich also has 
pressed the novel argument that the state's food and drug safety law, 
known as the Sherman Law, applies to sales of medical marijuana.

He reached the conclusion after he had asked a federal lab to test 
samples of marijuana that undercover police officers bought at 
dispensaries, including Hemp Factory V, and found pesticides, 
including some banned ones.

Chalfant agreed with Trutanich that selling medical marijuana would 
trigger the Sherman Law's requirements, which include labeling drugs 
properly and ensuring that they do not contain poisonous substances. 
In his order, Chalfant also barred Hemp Factory V from selling 
marijuana that contains pesticides. 
- ---
MAP posted-by: Richard Lake