Pubdate: Sat, 10 Dec 2011
Source: Montreal Gazette (CN QU)
Copyright: 2011 Canwest Publishing Inc.
Contact: http://www.canada.com/montrealgazette/letters.html
Website: http://www.montrealgazette.com/
Details: http://www.mapinc.org/media/274
Author: Charlie Fidelman, The Gazette 

PORTRAIT OF A PATIENT

A Survivor of Incest and Abuse, Francois Found Relief in Marijuana.
His Doctor and Psychiatrist Agree He Needs It. but He's Caught in A
Grey Area and Can't Get It Legally

It was a Thursday afternoon, June 3, 2010, and Francois was about to
knock on the door of the Montreal marijuana compassion club when he
saw a sign that made his heart race. Closed. By police.

So he ran straight to the mountain to his old scoring grounds in
search of a pot dealer. As he got closer, he heard someone whistle - a
warning.

Everyone scattered. With a trim build and moustache, "they took me for
a cop," says Francois, who is not an addict, a pusher, or a
recreational user.

He has post-traumatic stress disorder, a condition for which cannabis
has recognized therapeutic value.

A survivor of family violence, incest and sexual abuse, Francois, 43,
struggles with depression, sleep and loss of appetite, anxiety and
suicidal tendencies - symptoms that he says are alleviated by
marijuana, and his doctor and psychiatrist agree.

But a decade after Canada legalized marijuana to help treat certain
medical conditions, it remains a drug that Francois cannot buy or
"refill" at the pharmacy. So he relies on compassion clubs, otherwise
known as "medical cannabis dispensaries."

In June of that year, police arraigned 38 people on charges of
conspiracy, possession and drug trafficking after raiding four
Montreal-area compassion clubs and a fifth in Quebec City, including
two suspected of running high-traffic pot retail stores.

But the crackdown stranded hundreds of critically and chronically ill
patients, like Francois, who suddenly found themselves without access
to their medication for various painful conditions including cancer,
HIV/AIDS, epilepsy, multiple sclerosis and arthritis.

Most users turned to black market sources, "where they don't feel
safe. Some went to Ontario. Some died," said Marc-Boris St-Maurice,
founder and president of the Montreal Compassion Club who was among
those arrested.

Standing at the closed door that June day, Francois says he knew
instantly that he had to find a dealer on the street or he wouldn't
last the night.

"I'm still alive because of it," Francois says between sips of black
coffee at a cafe near his physician's clinic.

"My father came for me at night," Francois says. His mother put a
sedative in his drinking water "so the neighbours wouldn't hear me
scream and cry.

"Even today I am apprehensive about going to sleep - I know something
bad is going to happen to me."

Marijuana falls into a legal grey zone - it is recognized as
therapeutic, but it is still illegal to possess, unless a patient has
an exemption from Health Canada.

Without an authorization granted by Health Canada, which must first be
signed by a doctor, patients like Francois can be jailed for
possessing a drug that helps them function.

The number of exemptions issued between January 2010 and Nov. 1, 2011,
jumped from 4,884 to 12,225 and Health Canada has hired an additional
28 people to speed up the process.

However, Ottawa is proposing changes to the program that would give
doctors the final say on who receives such authorization.

Most doctors do not support the proposed changes and many were already
boycotting participating in the current authorization process, citing
a lack of proper medical research.

Last week, a nervous Francois fidgeted in his doctor's waiting
room.

"Today will be the day that my doctor will sign," he says,
optimistically patting the forms in his pocket.

Just last month, however, Canadian Medical Association president Dr.
John Haggie rejected Health Canada's proposed changes to the exemption
process, saying it places too much responsibility on the doctors who
sign the authorizations. The association says doctors should not be
the gatekeepers of a substance that's largely untested and unregulated
- - and still illegal.

Haggie's concerns were echoed by Dr. Yves Robert of the Quebec College
of Physicians, who called the drug policy a political paradox "that
seeks, at .. the same time, to crack down on the societal use of an
illegal product and to facilitate its use and access by a vulnerable
and suffering patient population."

At a recent consultation on the proposed changes to the Marijuana
Medical Access Program, Robert outlined three options: "The status
quo, legalizing marijuana, or treating the product as any other drug
or therapy.

"If marijuana is a drug, then Health Canada should treat it as such,
no more, no less. If marijuana is not a drug, then physicians should
not be asked to (prescribe) it."

Doctors and patients say Health Canada produces poor-quality medical
marijuana, leaving even patients with permits little choice but to
turn to illegal sources.

In the waiting room, Francois says he has an ace up his sleeve to 
persuade his doctor to sign the form.

He is referring to an affidavit signed by his psychiatrist that states
marijuana is as necessary to Francois's therapy as the medication he
takes for depression, psychosis and anxiety.

The youngest of three children, Francois was a thin boy with pale hair
and round blue eyes. Of his siblings, he suffered the worst abuse. "My
father said (that) I wasn't his real son" - a claim later disproven by
a DNA test.

"I'm his son," Francois says as he stares into his coffee. His father,
and tormentor, died before Francois could confront him about the abuse.

Francois says he never acknowledged the abuse until Quebec singer
Nathalie Simard spoke up in 2005 about her own abuse at the hands of
manager Guy Cloutier, who served 19 months of a 42-month sentence for
sexual abuse.

"I never admitted it, not even to myself, until it blew up in the
media," says Francois, who was suddenly confronting memories that he
couldn't live with - including a photograph of himself wearing a
wedding ring during a mock marriage ceremony to his father when he was
7.

There were beatings and broken bones, verbal abuse and nightly visits
- - and his mother's complicity. When he was in Grade 2, he confided in
a teacher and his priest, but instead of helping him, the intervention
led to even more violence at home.

"My father tried to kill me. That broke me. I knew there would be no
way out," Francois says.

His breaking point came in 2006 shortly after he started therapy for
abused men. A 13-year relationship ended. He couldn't sleep or eat. He
lost 75 pounds. He wanted to die.

"But I'm still alive," Francois says with a smile. It's something he
says often, a reminder of how close he came to not surviving.

Francois was already on medical leave of absence from work when he
walked past the Montreal Compassion Club, then on Rachel St.

"What do I need to do to come here?" he asked at the door. He was told
he needed a signed doctor's note.

At the time, his physician didn't hesitate. Already as thin as an
adolescent, Francois was wasting away, and cannabis reduces nausea and
improves appetite. "I was so happy the day my doctor signed," he says.
"I cried. It was the worst moment of my life. I was alone, in crisis,"
and continually revisiting painful memories.

At the club, Francois was given support, monitoring and a treatment
plan.

"They tried different varieties to see how it acted on me," says
Francois, who kept notes about the different strains of pot and what
effect they had on his appetite, sleep and anxiety.

His feeling of isolation started to lift. "For the first time in my
life I saw others with PTSD - I thought I was alone," says Francois,
who credits cannabis and "human resilience" for his return to a
full-time job with the city of Montreal after a three-year leave.

He is also entitled to a small pension under the Crime Victims
Compensation Act. It doesn't cover a fraction of his monthly $1,000
medical marijuana costs, which are not reimbursed by health insurers.

"At what price is well-being? I know what it does for my life," he
says, as the clinic intercom blasts his name in the waiting room.

Tired of living with the fear of getting caught, Francois is now
seeking his doctor's signature on the Health Canada forms - the same
physician who years ago signed off on his diagnosis and has continued
to follow his progress. At one point, she had prescribed synthetic
cannabis (which is covered by insurers), but it had no effect.

Once approved by Ottawa, the authorization he is seeking will allow
him to grow his own medical marijuana, have someone else grow it for
him, or buy it directly from Health Canada.

Francois appears half an hour later holding a renewal for
antidepressants in his hand.

He calmly stares into space at the pharmacy.

Did the doctor sign? His shoulders slump as he lets out a deflated
sigh. "She said, 'I can't sign, but I know it's beneficial for you.'"

His doctor doesn't want to become known as the go-to doctor for people
seeking marijuana.

Francois currently has safe access and consistent quality cannabis at
a medical marijuana dispensary that opened discretely after the raid.

"I'm so disappointed. If another bust happens, I'll have to go to the
mountain again," he says, head hanging.

On the other hand, he says suddenly smiling, "I'm still alive."
- ---
MAP posted-by: Richard R Smith Jr.