Source: San Diego Union Tribune (CA) 
Author: Dan Walters, The Sacramento Bee
Pubdate: Fri, 6 Mar 1998
Contact:  
Mail: Letters Editor, San Diego Union-Tribune, P O Box 191 San Diego, CA
92112-4106
Fax: (619) 293-1440
Website: http://www.uniontrib.com/ 

PRISON SYSTEM OUT OF CONTROL

The eight Corcoran State Prison guards indicted on federal cruelty charges
must, of course, be held personally responsible for their own actions,
whatever they were. Such accountability is, after all, the philosophical
core of the penal system itself.

But the semi-official line from the state Department of Corrections and the
Governor's Office -- that if there was wrongdoing, it was solely the
misdeeds of rogue guards -- is not acceptable. There's something more
fundamentally amiss with the department.

As any business executive knows, one of the most perilous circumstances is
unbridled, unmanaged growth, and the Department of Corrections has been, by
a wide margin, the state government's fastest-growing segment. It has added
dozens of new facilities, hired some 35,000 new employees, expanded its
spending 10-fold and absorbed more than 130,000 new inmates since 1980.

Californians and their political representatives demanded that expansion,
decreeing that those who commit felonies would be treated more harshly than
in the past. The state's crime rates have fallen since the prison-expansion
program began and its advocates and defenders credit it with that drop.
Whether that credit is warranted, or not, it's clear that the rapid
expansion of California's penal system has had several interlocking effects
on the system itself, to wit:

As tens of thousands of young men were sucked into the inmate population by
tougher new laws and harsher judicial and parole policies, many brought
with them gang-centered, violence-prone codes of conduct;

Despite construction of new prisons, the system was packed well beyond its
designed capacity, becoming a human warehousing network rather than a
correctional program;

Drug treatment, basic education, job counseling and other programs that
might have reduced recidivism were reduced to near-nothing by a lack of
money, a lack of space and a lack of political will;

Tens of thousands of new guards were hired, shoved into the cellblocks and
guard towers with minimal training and acculturation but imbued with
god-like powers over inmates;

Expansion and retirements meant rapid promotion into management of people
who were only scantily prepared, thus creating what one former Corrections
official calls "a loss of institutional leadership;"

The prisons themselves tended to operate as independent units, rather than
components of a centralized department accountable through politicians to
the public, with wardens viewing themselves as captains of warships on the
high seas;

An unholy political alliance developed between those who were supposed to
be managing Corrections, including the governor, and the California
Correctional Peace Officers Association, which became the state's single
most powerful labor union and lubricated its political relationships with
tons of campaign money;

Prison officials have restricted the ability of the media and legislators
to find out hat's been happening behind prison walls. Wilson and the
department also have resisted proposals to establish an independent
watchdog such as an inspector general - even though the governor says he
wants such an independent inspector for public schools.

Given all of those conditions, it's a minor miracle that California's
prison system hasn't experienced more misconduct and mismanagement. But the
conditions that bred what happened in Corcoran remain unaddressed. Indeed,
the indicted guards contend that they were only following departmental
orders when they put rival gang members together.

We -- taxpayers and voters -- should insist that those we elect get control
of an institution that appears to be out of control.

Copyright 1998 Union-Tribune Publishing Co.