Pubdate: Sun, 26 Dec 1999
Source: Washington Post (DC)
Copyright: 1999 The Washington Post Company
Address: 1150 15th Street Northwest, Washington, DC 20071
Feedback: http://washingtonpost.com/wp-srv/edit/letters/letterform.htm
Website: http://www.washingtonpost.com/
Author: Molly Moore, Washington Post Foreign Service
Note: Researcher Garance Burke contributed to this report.

HOSTILITY, VIOLENCE THREATEN RIGHTS DEFENDERS IN MEXICO

MEXICO CITY - Jose Angel Martinez, commander of a Mexican border police
unit created to aid immigrants, sensed he was in danger after handing his
superiors a report alleging high-level government involvement in drug
trafficking and immigrant smuggling.

He took his fears to the United Nations top human rights official, who was
touring Mexico. He called a local human rights group but got an answering
machine. He delivered a copy of his report to a leading newspaper
columnist. He confided to everyone he reached that he was terrified for his
life.

Within a few days, while making his rounds near Mexico's border with
Guatemala on Nov. 29, Martinez was shot through the heart at close range,
according to law enforcement and human rights officials.

"His death is a demonstration of the severity of the information contained
in that report," said Fabienne Venet, director of Without Borders, a
migrant advocacy group, and a longtime Martinez friend. "He told me about
some of it in private conversations, but I was out of town when he called.
When I heard, I knew he had called to say he feared for his life."

Martinez's death has rallied national and international human rights groups
alarmed by what they say has been an increase in attacks and threats
against human rights defenders in Mexico at a time when the country is
struggling to democratize a government and society ruled for 70 years by
the same political party.

"During the past few years a campaign to harass and persecute has been
waged against human rights defenders," was the assessment of All Rights for
All, a national network of 48 Mexican advocacy groups, in a recent report
that cited 113 incidents. "This campaign includes death threats,
surveillance, fabrication of crimes, intimidation and theft of information
and equipment."

U.N. High Commissioner for Human Rights Mary Robinson, who visited some of
Mexico's most troubled states last month, said the protection of human
rights activists, as well as others whose work involves rights issues, is a
major focus of her agenda here.

In response to the growing criticism, the Foreign Ministry said in a
statement this month that "the government of Mexico considers unacceptable
all acts that violate the integrity of people dedicated to the cause of
human rights in our country." Government officials referred reporters to
the statement when asked to comment for this article.

Although no organization has compiled a comprehensive list of activists,
journalists and local politicians who have been killed, arrested or
threatened as a result of their rights work, human rights groups documented
scores of cases this year.

Those incidents included an assault on a lawyer for the prominent Miguel
Agustin Pro Juarez Human Rights Center in Mexico City. She was tortured and
tied to a chair in her house on Oct. 28 and interrogated for eight hours
about her cases, including one in which she defended two environmental
activists allegedly tortured by the Mexican army during detention in the
Pacific Coast state of Guerrero.

The documented cases also included the killing of an activist who had
opposed a Boise Cascade Corp. logging project in Guerrero; death threats
received by a Roman Catholic priest in the southern state of Oaxaca in
April after he intervened in election-related rights cases; and threats
directed at activists in the northern industrial city of Monterrey who
tried to improve prison conditions.

To human rights advocates, no case better illustrates the dangers of
fighting the system than the killing of Martinez, commander of the Beta
Group, one of several Mexican police units charged with protecting the
rights of migrants along Mexico's borders.

Martinez, whom one human rights official described as "profoundly honest,"
had compiled a report describing the involvement of senior government
officials, prominent industrial leaders and federal police in the illegal
trafficking of drugs, migrants and weapons in Tabasco and Chiapas states.
Among those implicated were family members of a former Tabasco governor.

Three days before he died, Martinez telephoned Jorge Fernandez Menendez, a
prominent columnist for the daily Mexico City newspaper El Financero "to
tell me . . . that he was under a lot of pressure and that corruption was
overflowing because that border area had become one of the major routes for
drug and alien trafficking," Fernandez wrote.

Martinez gave the columnist a copy of his report, details of which
Fernandez published after Martinez was killed.

Authorities have charged Anacarsis Peralta, a colleague of Martinez, with
murder. Miguel Rodriquez, Peralta's attorney, said Peralta told police that
the shooting was accidental and that he tried to get Martinez to a hospital
after the gun went off.

Jorge Canel, administrative coordinator of the National Migration Institute
in Tabasco, said some agency officials believe "somebody paid [the killer]
to be the trigger man."

In addition to physical violence and threats, human rights organizations
increasingly are verbally assaulted by politicians, business leaders and
church officials. Rights workers were stunned earlier this year when
Cardinal Juan Sandoval in the central state of Jalisco launched a tirade
against the state human rights commission for "constantly defending
delinquents."

The cardinal added: "Human rights are not in question. Rather, in question,
is this human rights organization whose work has not been beneficial to
society."

"As crime gets worse, people legitimately want some state response," said
Joel Solomon, Americas research director for Human Rights Watch, an
international monitoring organization. "Human rights groups are seen as a
straitjacket in the fight against crime. It's a lot easier to blame human
rights procedures than it is to resolve the fundamental problem."

National and international human rights organizations praise Mexico for
signing several global conventions on human rights in recent years and
establishing a national human rights commission to investigate offenses.
But the organizations criticize the commission and the government for their
failure to adequately investigate and prosecute offenders.

"Mexico considers it important to develop a culture of human rights at all
levels [and] to strengthen institutions charged with bringing justice and
stopping impunity," said the Foreign Ministry.

Researcher Garance Burke contributed to this report.
- ---
MAP posted-by: Jo-D