HTTP/1.0 200 OK
Content-Type: text/html
It's Time for Canada to Legalize Cannabis
Pubdate: Fri, 25 Feb 2005
Source: Toronto Star (CN ON)
Copyright: 2005 The Toronto Star
Contact: http://www.thestar.com/
Details: http://www.mapinc.org/media/456
Author: Wayne G. Cook
Note: Wayne G. Cook is a member of the Toronto Star's community editorial
board.
Bookmark: http://www.mapinc.org/mjcn.htm (Cannabis - Canada)
Bookmark: http://www.mapinc.org/decrim.htm (Decrim/Legalization)
IT'S TIME FOR CANADA TO LEGALIZE CANNABIS
The use of cannabis is widespread and there is intermittent talk from
the government of Canada regarding "decriminalizing," but not about
legalizing, it. Cannabis has much in common with both alcohol and
tobacco products. Each at various times has been demonized, banned,
criminalized and targeted as a health risk. We can learn from these
experiences.
What can we learn from alcohol? First, banning doesn't work. As
attempts at prohibition proves, it turns this area of the economy over
to criminals and gives ordinary citizens criminal records.
Second, although there are definite health hazards for some, there are
also putative benefits and people for millennia have ignored any
claimed risks. Accordingly, we have decided that such a large group
has a right to make its own decision.
Third, the system the Liquor Control Board of Ontario uses to control
alcohol distribution is effective. Alcohol is available to adults, its
purity is assured, there is a minimal black market and the province
gets considerable revenue.
We also know there is a downside to alcohol and assistance is given to
problem drinkers. There are protections against drunk drivers, for
example. Controlled distribution is an effective compromise for this
product.
What can we learn from tobacco products?
All the evidence from the last 30 years indicates that tobacco is
dangerous for the health of both smokers and anyone who regularly
inhales second-hand smoke. Despite these risks, some will still smoke
and we have decided adults have the right to make their own decisions.
Accordingly, tobacco products remain legal for adults. Tobacco
products are also extremely addictive, so we put many controls on
them. Smoking in public places has been restricted, tobacco products
are taxed heavily to reduce the demand and promotion has been
virtually eliminated in an effort to reduce the number of new smokers,
especially among the young.
We are reaching an effective compromise that protects smokers,
non-smokers, and minors.
What lessons can we draw from these experiences for cannabis?
Concerning health, as far back as 1972 the LeDain Royal Commission on
the Non-Medical Use of Drugs reported that "the physical and mental
effects of cannabis would appear to be much less serious than those
which may result from excessive use of alcohol."
This statement appears true 30 years later. More recently, there are
claimed health benefits, especially to some who suffer from certain
illnesses. All in all, this is a situation that calls for personal
choice, but with appropriate controls.
So what should be the preferred path?
First, the federal government should make the use of cannabis products
legal: Decriminalization is not sufficient.
Second, a safe, regulated supply should be made available, perhaps
through a CCBO or Cannabis Control Board of Ontario.
These steps would guarantee product purity, take criminals out of this
area of the economy, provide tax revenues, allow police to concentrate
on more serious crime and stop the harassment of ordinary citizens.
Existing R.I.D.E. programs can be used to help control irresponsible
drivers, and the use of designated drivers can be adopted from our
experience with alcohol.
One of the major benefits will be to reduce the availability of pot to
minors. If this seems counterintuitive, just ask any teenager which is
more available to them, alcohol or cannabis? Drug dealers don't ask
for proof-of-age.
Cannabis use is so pervasive that its use may go almost unnoticed if
it were legalized. It will have benefits all around, not the least of
which will be the capture of money that now goes to criminals.
Naturally, moralists will object to this "sin" being legalized and
wish to impose their beliefs on others. Surely, we can overcome this
attitude in modern Canada.
The other issue is the reaction of the United States, whose absurd,
counterproductive "war on drugs" is opposed to any tolerance for
recreational drugs. Controlled distribution in Canada should minimize
the amount of legal cannabis that goes to the U.S., as it does with
alcohol. Perhaps, in time, Americans will learn from our experience
and soften their attitude.
Most arguments against cannabis legalization are moralistic, whereas
the arguments in favour are pragmatic and would help to protect
minors, users, and society.
The time has come to legalize cannabis.
- ---
MAP posted-by: Richard Lake